Best for runners
NordicTrack Commercial 1750
FitScore for Class Training
- Motor4.25 HP
- Running Surface22 × 60 in
- Weight Capacity400 lb
- Incline–3% to 12%
Choose it if you want iFIT classes plus decline, a wider deck and a frame that folds.
Best for Peloton fans
Peloton Tread
FitScore for Class Training
- Motor3 HP
- Running Surface20 × 59 in
- Weight Capacity300 lb
- Incline0–12.5%
Choose it if Peloton classes keep you motivated and floor space is permanent.
Overall winner for class training: NordicTrack Commercial 1750. It pairs iFIT classes with a stronger motor, decline, a wider cushioned deck, a 400-lb rating and a frame that folds. The Peloton Tread is the better choice if Peloton classes are the reason you train and you have a permanent spot for a non-folding treadmill.
NordicTrack Commercial 1750 wins 3 rounds- Peloton Tread wins 1 round
- =1 tie
Product photos from Amazon. FitScore weights are explained below.
NordicTrack 1750 vs Peloton: The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 and the Peloton Tread are both built around streamed classes: each has a large touchscreen, a motorized incline and a membership that unlocks the workout library. Under the screen they differ a lot. The 1750 has a 4.25 HP motor, a –3% to 12% incline range, a 22 × 60-inch cushioned deck, a 400-lb rating and a folding frame; the Tread has a 24-inch swivel screen, 12.5 mph and 12.5% incline on a 20 × 59-inch belt, a 300-lb rating and a frame that does not fold.
The Commercial 1750 ranks #3 in our best treadmill for HIIT and best treadmill for cardio guides. The Peloton Tread ranks #4 in our best treadmill with classes guide and #5 in our best premium treadmill guide. For the full picture, read our NordicTrack Commercial 1750 review and Peloton Tread review.
Head-to-Head Specs
Here are the two models side by side, from their Amazon US listings. A check mark shows the stronger spec on each line. In May 2021, Peloton and the CPSC recalled about 1,050 Peloton Tread treadmills (model TR02) sold in the U.S., because the touchscreen could detach and fall; Peloton offered a free repair. On a used Tread, ask whether the repair was done (see the CPSC recall notice). The American Heart Association recommends at least 150 minutes of moderate or 75 minutes of vigorous aerobic activity a week. If you train for road races, a 1996 study of trained runners found that a 1% incline best matched the energy cost of outdoor running at about 6.5 to 11 mph.
| Specification | NordicTrack Commercial 1750FitScore 93.1 | Peloton TreadFitScore 81.8 |
|---|---|---|
| Motor | 4.25 HP✓ | 3 HP |
| Speed | 0–12 mph | 1–12.5 mph✓ |
| Incline | –3% to 12%✓ | 0–12.5% |
| Running Surface | 22 × 60 in✓ | 20 × 59 in |
| Cushioning | RunFlex✓ | Not specified |
| Weight Capacity | 400 lb✓ | 300 lb |
| Screen | 16-in pivoting touchscreen | 24-in touchscreen, 360° swivel✓ |
| Membership | iFIT Pro for classes and connected features | Peloton All-Access for classes |
| Folding | Yes✓ | No |
| Assembled Size | 77.3 × 37 × 59.5 in | 68 × 33 × 65 in✓ |
| Product Weight | About 266 lb | About 258 lb |
| Warranty (as listed) | 2 years frame, motor, parts and labor✓ | 12 months frame, motor, parts and labor |
| Specs won | 7 of 12 | 3 of 12 |
Check Amazon for current pricing and availability.
FitScore Duel
Both scores use the weights of our best treadmill with classes guide: features 70%, performance 10%, and durability, comfort, practicality and affordability 5% each. Class buyers choose a treadmill for its screen, library and automatic speed and incline control first, so features dominate. Both score high on features (100 for the 1750, 90 for the Tread); the 1750 then pulls ahead on performance, durability and comfort thanks to its motor, decline, wider deck and higher weight rating. The Commercial 1750 is not one of the five treadmills ranked in that guide, so its score simply uses the same weights.
Key Differences
- The 1750 has a 16-inch pivoting touchscreen and runs iFIT; the Tread has a 24-inch screen that swivels 360° and runs Peloton classes.
- The 1750 adds a 3% decline and a 4.25 HP motor; the Tread has a 3 HP motor and no decline.
- The 1750’s deck is 22 × 60 inches with RunFlex cushioning; the Tread’s belt is 20 × 59 inches.
- The 1750 is rated for 400 lb, the Tread for 300 lb.
- The 1750 folds; the Tread does not, but it takes less floor space (68 × 33 inches against 77.3 × 37).
- Each needs its own membership for classes: iFIT Pro on the 1750, Peloton All-Access on the Tread.
Round 1 of 5
NordicTrack 1750 vs Peloton: Screen, Classes and Membership
Tie. Neither model has a clear edge here.
The Tread’s 24-inch screen swivels all the way round for off-treadmill classes, and testers describe its class library as polished, with handrail knobs that make speed and incline changes quick. The 1750’s 16-inch screen pivots for the same kind of floor workouts, and iFIT trainers change its speed and incline for you during classes and outdoor-route workouts.
Both are built around a paid plan: testers consider the Peloton membership essential to getting value from the Tread, and they note that the 1750 leans heavily on a Wi-Fi connection and an iFIT membership too. If you already train with Peloton, the Tread keeps everything in one place; if you want a wider mix of routes and trainers that drive the incline, iFIT on the 1750 does more.
Round 2 of 5
Motor, Speed and Incline
NordicTrack Commercial 1750 wins this round
The 1750 lists a 4.25 HP motor with 0–12 mph and a –3% to 12% incline, a range testers single out because iFIT routes use the decline to mimic downhill sections. The Tread runs from 1 to 12.5 mph and up to 12.5% incline, with no decline.
Testers describe the current 1750 as heavy and very stable under hard running, and they found the Tread’s belt speed accurate. For intervals and hill-and-valley routes, the decline and the stronger motor give the 1750 the edge.
Round 3 of 5
Running Deck and Cushioning
NordicTrack Commercial 1750 wins this round
The 1750’s 22 × 60-inch deck uses RunFlex cushioning, which testers describe as roomy and cushioned. The Tread’s belt is 20 × 59 inches, and testers found it slightly short for long strides and firmer than they expected.
If you run often, or share the treadmill with a taller runner, the two extra inches of width and the softer deck make the 1750 more forgiving.
Round 4 of 5
Footprint, Folding and Noise
Peloton Tread wins this round
The Tread needs about 68 × 33 inches of floor and does not fold. The 1750 needs about 77.3 × 37 inches and folds to about 44.2 inches deep, but it stands about 69 inches tall when folded and has a 10-inch step-up height.
Testers report that the 1750 is hard to move once built, and that the Tread is heavy and needs dedicated space. One outlet measured the Tread louder than average. Put either on a mat in an apartment or an upstairs room.
Round 5 of 5
Build, Capacity and Warranty
NordicTrack Commercial 1750 wins this round
The 1750 is rated for 400 lb against 300 lb for the Tread, and testers describe it as one of the most stable treadmills in its class. Its main drawback is a long two-person assembly.
The Amazon listings give 2 years on the 1750’s frame, motor, parts and labor, and 12 months on the Tread’s frame, motor, parts and labor. Testers flag the Tread’s short frame warranty as a weak point for a treadmill at this level.
Who Should Buy Each
Runners who want classes and a folding frame
Choose the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 for iFIT classes on a 16-inch screen, a –3% to 12% incline, a 22 × 60-inch deck and a 400-lb rating.
Peloton members with a permanent spot
Choose the Peloton Tread for Peloton classes on a 24-inch swivel screen, handrail knobs and a smaller footprint.
Consider Instead
If you want the biggest iFIT screen, NordicTrack’s Commercial 2450 adds a 24-inch screen and 14 mph; see how it stacks up in our Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack 2450 comparison, or compare the two NordicTrack models in our NordicTrack 1750 vs 2450 guide. For every class-led pick, browse our best treadmill with classes guide.
Final Verdict
For most people who want classes and real running performance, the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 is the better buy: iFIT classes that control the treadmill, decline, a wider cushioned deck, a 400-lb rating, a folding frame and longer listed coverage. Choose the Peloton Tread if Peloton classes are what keep you training, and you are happy to give it a permanent spot.
NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs Peloton Tread FAQ
For class training with harder running, yes: it scores 93.1 against 81.8 with a stronger motor, decline, a 22 × 60-inch deck, a 400-lb rating and a folding frame. The Tread wins on screen size and footprint.
The 1750 runs iFIT on a 16-inch screen, folds and adds a 3% decline. The Tread runs Peloton classes on a 24-inch swivel screen, does not fold and has no decline.
Yes, for classes. The 1750 needs an iFIT membership for its content and connected features; the Tread needs a Peloton All-Access Membership.
The Peloton Tread, with a 24-inch touchscreen that swivels 360°. The 1750 has a 16-inch screen that pivots.
No. The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 does, to about 44 inches deep, though it stands about 69 inches tall when folded.
The NordicTrack Commercial 1750, at 400 lb against 300 lb for the Peloton Tread.
The 1750, per the Amazon listings: 2 years on the frame, motor, parts and labor, against 12 months on each for the Tread.
Explore More Treadmill Guides
NordicTrack Commercial 1750 Review
Peloton Tread Review
Best Treadmill With Classes (2026): 5 Connected Training Picks
Best Premium Treadmill Picks for 2026: 5 High-End Options Worth Buying
Best Treadmill for HIIT and Interval Training (2026): 5 Picks
Best Treadmill for Cardio (2026): 5 Strong Home Picks
This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We do not show prices because they change constantly: product details and availability can change at any time, so please check the current price and details directly on Amazon. Learn more. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.
