The Peloton Tread and NordicTrack Commercial 2450 are both connected treadmills built around a 24-inch touchscreen and a required membership: Peloton All-Access on the Tread, iFIT Pro on the 2450. The 2450 adds a stronger motor, 14 mph, –3% decline, a wider 22 × 60-inch deck, a 400-lb rating and a folding frame; the Tread offers a screen that swivels 360°, handrail speed and incline knobs and a smaller footprint.
The 2450 ranks #2 and the Tread ranks #4 in our best treadmill with classes guide. For more detail on the NordicTrack, read our NordicTrack Commercial 2450 review.
Quick Verdict
Overall winner for streaming classes: NordicTrack Commercial 2450. It pairs a 24-inch tilt-and-pivot touchscreen and iFIT classes with a 4.25 HP motor, 14 mph, –3% to 12% incline, a 22 × 60-inch deck, a 400-lb rating and a folding frame. The Peloton Tread is the better fit if Peloton classes are what keep you training and you have a permanent spot for it.
BEST OVERALL
NordicTrack Commercial 2450
FitScore 92.8/100
Choose it if you want iFIT classes plus serious running specs, decline and a folding frame.
BEST FOR PELOTON CLASSES
Peloton Tread
FitScore 81.8/100
Choose it if Peloton classes keep you consistent and you do not need folding.
Head-to-Head Specs
Here are the two models side by side, based on the manufacturer listings. A check mark shows the stronger spec on each line.
| Comparehead to head | WinnerBEST OVERALL | BEST FOR PELOTON CLASSES |
|---|---|---|
| Motor | 4.25 HP ✓ | 3 HP |
| Speed | 0–14 mph ✓ | 1–12.5 mph |
| Incline | 0–12% | 0–12.5% ✓ |
| Decline | Up to –3% ✓ | None |
| Running Surface | 22 × 60 in ✓ | 20 × 59 in |
| Weight Capacity | 400 lb ✓ | 300 lb |
| Touchscreen | 24-in, tilts and pivots | 24-in HD, swivels 360° |
| Folding | Yes, assisted lowering ✓ | No |
| Footprint | 77.3 × 37 in | 68 × 33 in ✓ |
| Membership | iFIT Pro required for iFIT content and connected features | Peloton All-Access required |
| Warranty (as listed) | 10-yr frame, lifetime motor, 2-yr parts, 1-yr labor ✓ | 12 months frame, motor, parts and labor |
| Specs won (✓) Lines where the model has the stronger spec; ties count for neither | 7 of 11 | 2 of 11 |
| Check Price | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
Check Amazon for current pricing and availability.
FitScore Duel
Both scores use the weights of our best treadmill with classes guide: features 70%, performance 10%, and durability, comfort, practicality and affordability 5% each. For class-driven buyers, the screen, the class library and the connected features are what you pay for, so they count most. The 2450 leads in every category, with the largest gaps on features, durability and comfort, which explains the 11-point difference.
NordicTrack Commercial 2450
Peloton Tread
Key Differences
- The 2450 reaches 14 mph with a 4.25 HP motor; the Tread tops out at 12.5 mph with a 3 HP motor.
- The 2450 goes down to –3% decline; the Tread has no decline but climbs to 12.5% instead of 12%.
- The 2450 has a 22 × 60-inch deck and a 400-lb rating; the Tread a 20 × 59-inch deck and a 300-lb rating.
- The 2450 folds; the Tread does not, but it needs less floor space.
- The 2450 runs on iFIT and the Tread on Peloton All-Access, and each needs its membership for classes.
- The 2450 lists a 10-year frame and lifetime motor warranty; the Tread lists 12 months.
Screen and Class Experience
Both have a 24-inch touchscreen you can turn for off-treadmill classes such as strength and yoga. The 2450’s screen tilts and pivots, and the Tread’s swivels 360° for 15+ workout types.
Testers describe the Tread’s class experience as polished and like its handrail knobs for quick speed and incline changes. On the 2450, testers found few physical buttons for precise speed changes, since most adjustments run through the screen, although they say the large screen and iFIT content make workouts more motivating.
Winner: Peloton Tread
Membership and Connected Features
The Tread requires a Peloton All-Access Membership, which provides the class library and personalized weekly routines. Testers consider it essential to getting value from the machine.
The 2450 needs an iFIT Pro membership for iFIT content and connected features, and it covers your whole household. It adds SmartAdjust, which changes speed and incline based on your workout history, ActivePulse for heart rate zone training with a Bluetooth monitor, and syncing with Strava, Garmin Connect and Apple Health. Some owners mention constant app prompts and a fiddly setup.
Winner: NordicTrack Commercial 2450
Running Specs and Deck
The 2450’s 4.25 HP motor reaches 14 mph, and its incline runs from –3% to 12%. One independent test measured about 12.5 seconds to go from 2 to 8 mph. The Tread covers 1 to 12.5 mph and up to 12.5% incline, and testers found its belt speed accurate.
The 2450’s 22 × 60-inch deck uses RunFlex cushioning, which testers describe as relatively soft. The Tread’s 20 × 59-inch belt offers some shock absorption without a truly cushioned feel, which matters if you have sensitive joints.
Winner: NordicTrack Commercial 2450
Footprint, Folding and Noise
The Tread needs about 68 × 33 inches of floor space but does not fold. The 2450 needs about 77 × 37 inches assembled and folds to a depth of about 44 inches, though it stands about 69 inches tall when folded and has a 10-inch step-up height.
Some testers measured the Tread a few decibels louder than typical rivals, and one test measured about 65 dB for the 2450. A mat helps with either in apartments and upstairs rooms.
Winner: Tie
Build, Capacity and Warranty
Owners describe the 2450 as a solid, commercial-grade treadmill, and testers found it stable with a tester close to 300 lb, although opinions on long-term reliability and value are divided. Owners also rate the Tread’s build quality highly.
The 2450 is rated for 400 lb against 300 lb for the Tread. Its listed warranty covers the frame for 10 years and the motor for life, with 2 years on parts and 1 year on labor; the Tread lists 12 months on the frame, motor, parts and labor.
Winner: NordicTrack Commercial 2450
Who Should Buy Each
Class fans who also run hard: Choose the NordicTrack Commercial 2450 for iFIT classes on a 24-inch screen, 14 mph, decline, a 400-lb rating and a folding frame.
Peloton members: Choose the Peloton Tread for Peloton classes on a 360° swivel screen, handrail knobs and a smaller footprint.
Consider Instead
If you want iFIT classes on a folding frame with a 16-inch touchscreen, read our Peloton Tread vs ProForm Pro 9000 comparison. For more screen-based options, see our best treadmill with screen guide.
Final Verdict
For most class-driven home gyms, the NordicTrack Commercial 2450 is the better buy: a 24-inch tilt-and-pivot screen and iFIT classes, plus 14 mph, decline, a wider deck, a 400-lb rating, a folding frame and longer frame and motor coverage. Choose the Peloton Tread if Peloton classes are what keep you training and you have a permanent spot for a non-folding treadmill.
NordicTrack Commercial 2450 vs Peloton Tread FAQ
For most buyers, yes: it scores higher overall with 14 mph, –3% decline, a 22 × 60-inch deck, a 400-lb rating, a folding frame and longer frame and motor coverage. The Peloton Tread is the better choice if you prefer Peloton classes.
Both have a 24-inch touchscreen and need a membership. The 2450 uses iFIT, runs faster, adds decline, has a wider deck and folds. The Tread uses Peloton All-Access, has a 360° swivel screen and handrail knobs and takes less floor space.
Yes. The Peloton Tread requires a Peloton All-Access Membership, and the 2450 needs an iFIT Pro membership for iFIT content and connected features. Check the current membership terms on each product page.
Only the 2450, which goes down to –3%. The Tread runs from 0 to 12.5% incline.
No. The 2450 folds with assisted lowering, while the Tread does not fold and needs a permanent spot of about 68 × 33 inches.
The 2450 is listed at 400 lb and the Tread at 300 lb.
The 2450 lists 10 years on the frame, lifetime on the motor, 2 years on parts and 1 year on labor. The Tread lists 12 months on the frame, motor, parts and labor, so confirm the current terms on the product page.
Explore More Treadmill Guides
NordicTrack Commercial 2450 Review
Peloton Tread Review
Best Treadmill With Classes (2026): 5 Connected Training Picks
Best Premium Treadmill Picks for 2026: 5 High-End Options Worth Buying
Best Treadmill With Screen (2026): Top 5 Picks
Best Treadmill Without Subscription (2026): 5 Picks With No Required Paid Plan
This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We do not show prices because they change constantly: product details and availability can change at any time, so please check the current price and details directly on Amazon. Learn more. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.
