The NordicTrack Commercial 1250 and 1750 are built on the same platform: a folding frame with a 22 × 60-inch RunFlex deck, 0–12 mph, –3% to 12% incline, a 400-lb rating and the same listed footprint. The 1750 adds a stronger 4.25 HP motor and a 16-inch pivoting touchscreen; the 1250 runs a 3.6 HP motor with a 10-inch tilting touchscreen. Both need an iFIT membership for classes and connected features.
The 1250 ranks #3 in our best durable treadmill guide and #5 in our best treadmill for marathon training and best commercial treadmill guides. The 1750 ranks #3 in our best treadmill for HIIT and best treadmill for cardio guides. For more detail, read our NordicTrack Commercial 1250 review and NordicTrack Commercial 1750 review.
Quick Verdict
Overall winner for durability-focused buyers: NordicTrack Commercial 1250. It shares the 1750’s deck, incline and decline range, 400-lb rating, folding frame and listed warranty, and it scores higher on durability and affordability in our model. The Commercial 1750 is the better fit if you want the stronger motor and a 16-inch pivoting screen for iFIT classes.
BEST VALUE
NordicTrack Commercial 1250
FitScore 84.1/100
Choose it if you want the Commercial deck, decline and 400-lb rating and do not need the bigger screen.
BEST FOR BIG-SCREEN CLASSES
NordicTrack Commercial 1750
FitScore 81.5/100
Choose it if you want a 4.25 HP motor and a 16-inch pivoting screen for classes.
Head-to-Head Specs
Here are the two models side by side, based on the manufacturer listings. A check mark shows the stronger spec on each line.
| Comparehead to head | WinnerBEST VALUE | BEST FOR BIG-SCREEN CLASSES |
|---|---|---|
| Motor | 3.6 HP | 4.25 HP ✓ |
| Speed | 0–12 mph | 0–12 mph |
| Incline | –3% to 12% | –3% to 12% |
| Running Surface | 22 × 60 in | 22 × 60 in |
| Weight Capacity | 400 lb | 400 lb |
| Touchscreen | 10-in, tilts | 16-in, pivots ✓ |
| Cushioning | RunFlex | RunFlex |
| Footprint | 77.3 × 37 in | 77.3 × 37 in |
| Folded Size | 44.2 × 37 × 69 in | 44.2 × 37 × 69 in |
| Product Weight | About 300 lb (as listed) | About 266 lb (as listed) |
| Warranty (as listed) | 2 years frame, motor, parts and labor | 2 years frame, motor, parts and labor |
| Specs won (✓) Lines where the model has the stronger spec; ties count for neither | 0 of 11 | 2 of 11 |
| Check Price | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
Check Amazon for current pricing and availability.
FitScore Duel
Both scores use the weights of our best durable treadmill guide: durability 55%, performance 20%, comfort 10%, and practicality, features and affordability 5% each. If you want a treadmill that holds up to years of regular use, build and stability matter far more than screen size, so durability carries most of the weight. The 1750 is not ranked in that guide, but its score uses the same weights. It leads on performance and features, but the 1250 scores 5 points higher on durability and 15 on affordability, which explains the 2.6-point gap.
NordicTrack Commercial 1250
NordicTrack Commercial 1750
Key Differences
- The 1750 has a 4.25 HP motor; the 1250 a 3.6 HP motor. Both top out at 12 mph.
- The 1750 has a 16-inch touchscreen that pivots; the 1250 a 10-inch touchscreen that tilts.
- Deck size, RunFlex cushioning, –3% to 12% incline and the 400-lb rating are the same.
- Both fold to the same listed size and need the same floor space when open.
- The listed warranty is the same: 2 years on the frame, motor, parts and labor.
- Both need an iFIT membership for classes and connected features.
Build and Stability
Owners describe NordicTrack’s Commercial Series as solidly built and commercial-feeling, and say it stays quiet even at higher speeds. Opinions on long-term reliability are divided, with some owners reporting units that stopped working.
Independent testers found the 1250 very stable with no wobble at 10 mph, and one tester described the 1750 as built like a tank. Both share the 400-lb rating and the same frame dimensions, and the 1250 scores slightly higher on durability in our model.
Winner: NordicTrack Commercial 1250
Motor, Speed and Incline
The 1750’s 4.25 HP motor gives more headroom than the 1250’s 3.6 HP, which matters for heavier users and long sessions at incline. Independent testers found the 1750’s motor handled everything from recovery walks to marathon training, though they measured about a 4% speed variance that may need calibrating.
Speed and incline are otherwise identical: 0 to 12 mph and –3% decline to 12% incline. Testers found the 1250’s incline transitions smooth across that range.
Winner: NordicTrack Commercial 1750
Running Deck and Cushioning
Both use a 22 × 60-inch deck with RunFlex cushioning. One tester called the 1250’s RunFlex deck one of the best cushioned decks they have tried and found the belt roomy for tall runners.
Since the deck is the same on both, there is no practical difference underfoot.
Winner: Tie
Screen, Classes and Controls
The 1750’s 16-inch screen pivots for off-treadmill classes such as yoga and strength; the 1250’s 10-inch screen tilts. Testers found the 1250’s smaller screen harder to read than the 1750’s.
Both rely on iFIT Pro for classes, SmartAdjust, ActivePulse heart rate training with a Bluetooth monitor and syncing with Strava, Garmin Connect and Apple Health. Owners of both report that the on-screen controls can feel fiddly for quick speed changes, and testers note that without iFIT the 1250 offers only manual mode and a few basic workouts.
Winner: NordicTrack Commercial 1750
Footprint, Folding and Warranty
Both need about 77.3 × 37 inches of floor space and fold with assisted lowering to about 44 inches deep and 69 inches tall. Testers found the fold smooth but the folded machine still bulky and heavy to move, and one test team noted that the assembled 1750 is too wide for standard doorways.
The listings show the same 2-year coverage on the frame, motor, parts and labor for both, so confirm the current terms on the product page.
Winner: Tie
Who Should Buy Each
Buyers who want the core Commercial build: Choose the NordicTrack Commercial 1250 for the same deck, decline, 400-lb rating and folding frame with a smaller 10-inch screen.
iFIT class fans: Choose the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 for a 4.25 HP motor and a 16-inch pivoting screen for on- and off-treadmill classes.
Consider Instead
If you want a lighter folding treadmill with a longer listed frame warranty, the NordicTrack T Series 10 weighs about 210 lb, lists 10 years on the frame and has SelectFlex cushioning you can adjust from soft to firm, though it has no decline and a 325-lb rating. It ranks #2 in our best treadmill with cushioning guide. For more heavy-duty options, see our best durable treadmill guide.
Final Verdict
For most buyers who care about build and long-term use, the NordicTrack Commercial 1250 is the better buy: it has the same deck, cushioning, incline and decline range, 400-lb rating, folding frame and listed warranty as the 1750. Choose the Commercial 1750 if you want the stronger 4.25 HP motor and plan to follow iFIT classes on its 16-inch pivoting screen.
NordicTrack Commercial 1250 vs NordicTrack Commercial 1750 FAQ
For durability-focused buyers, yes: it scores 84.1 to the 1750’s 81.5 with the same deck, incline range, weight limit and listed warranty. The 1750 is better if you want a stronger motor and a bigger screen.
The 1750 has a 4.25 HP motor and a 16-inch pivoting touchscreen; the 1250 has a 3.6 HP motor and a 10-inch tilting touchscreen. Deck, speed, incline, decline and weight limit are the same.
Yes. Both have a 22 × 60-inch running surface with RunFlex cushioning.
Yes. Both go from –3% decline to 12% incline.
iFIT Pro is required for classes and connected features on both. Check the current membership terms on the product page.
Yes. Both fold with assisted lowering to about 44 × 37 × 69 inches.
Neither. Both list 2 years on the frame, motor, parts and labor, so confirm the current terms on the product page.
Explore More Treadmill Guides
This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We do not show prices because they change constantly: product details and availability can change at any time, so please check the current price and details directly on Amazon. Learn more. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.
