Head-to-head treadmill comparisons: model vs model, brand vs brand, and treadmills against other cardio options. Every model comparison scores both treadmills with the same FitScore weighting, so the winner reflects one buying intent, not a generic rating.
Prefer a single verdict? See our treadmill reviews or the ranked best treadmill guides.
Model vs Model
Two treadmills, the same FitScore weighting, one winner for a clear buying intent.
ProForm Pro 9000 vs Peloton Tread
Overall winner for streaming classes: ProForm Pro 9000. It pairs a 16-inch pivoting touchscreen and iFIT classes with a 3.6 HP motor, ProShox…
See the winner →
NordicTrack Commercial 2450 vs Peloton Tread
Overall winner for streaming classes: NordicTrack Commercial 2450. It pairs a 24-inch tilt-and-pivot touchscreen and iFIT classes with a 4.25 HP…
See the winner →
ProForm Pro 9000 vs NordicTrack Commercial 2450
A tie on FitScore for screen-based training: both score 91.7. The choice comes down to how you train and where the treadmill will go. The NordicTrack…
See the winner →
NordicTrack Commercial 2450 vs Sole F89
Overall winner for premium home use: NordicTrack Commercial 2450, by a small margin. It offers 14 mph, a 24-inch tilting touchscreen, a 400-lb rating…
See the winner →
Horizon 7.4 AT vs Horizon 7.0 AT
Overall winner for runners: Horizon 7.4 AT. It has a stronger 3.5 CHP motor, a 22-inch deck, a 350-lb rating and longer parts and labor coverage. The…
See the winner →
Horizon 7.4 AT vs Sole F80
Overall winner for runners: Horizon 7.4 AT. Its QuickDial controls make interval changes fast, its zoned cushioning scores higher for running…
See the winner →
Sole F80 vs NordicTrack Commercial 1750
Overall winner for runners: Sole F80, by a small margin. It pairs a 22 × 60-inch deck and 12 mph with 15% incline, heart rate programs, no required…
See the winner →
NordicTrack Commercial 2450 vs NordicTrack Commercial 1750
Overall winner for HIIT: NordicTrack Commercial 2450, by a small margin. Its 14 mph top speed and 24-inch screen suit sprint intervals and…
See the winner →
NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs ProForm Pro 9000
Overall winner for HIIT: NordicTrack Commercial 1750. Its 4.25 HP motor, –3% to 12% incline range, wider 22 × 60-inch deck and 400-lb rating give it…
See the winner →
Horizon 7.4 AT vs Sole F65
Overall winner for jogging: Horizon 7.4 AT. On the same deck size and incline range, it adds a stronger motor, QuickDial controls for quick pace…
See the winner →
Sole F80 vs Sole F65
Overall winner for jogging: Sole F80, by a small margin. Its touchscreen, 20 programs and lighter listed weight give it the edge on features and…
See the winner →
NordicTrack Commercial 1250 vs NordicTrack Commercial 1750
Overall winner for durability-focused buyers: NordicTrack Commercial 1250. It shares the 1750's deck, incline and decline range, 400-lb rating,…
See the winner →
NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs NordicTrack T Series 10
Overall winner for cardio: NordicTrack Commercial 1750, by a small margin. Its 4.25 HP motor, –3% decline, wider 22 × 60-inch deck, 400-lb rating and…
See the winner →
Horizon 7.0 AT vs Sole F63 (2026)
Overall winner: Horizon 7.0 AT. On the same motor rating, speed, incline, deck size and weight limit, it adds softer zoned cushioning, an included…
See the winner →
Horizon 7.0 AT vs Horizon T202
Overall winner: Horizon 7.0 AT. On the same deck size, it adds a stronger motor with quicker speed and incline changes, 15% incline, more programs,…
See the winner →
Sole F63 (2026) vs Horizon T101
Overall winner: F63. It lists a stronger 3 HP brushless motor, 12 mph, 15% incline, a full 60-inch deck, a 325-lb rating, more programs and 2 years…
See the winner →
Horizon T202 vs Horizon T101
Overall winner on a budget: Horizon T202, by a small margin. Its 60-inch deck, 12 mph top speed, 12% incline and 325-lb rating give it more room to…
See the winner →
ProForm Carbon TLX vs ProForm Carbon TL
Overall winner for budget buyers: ProForm Carbon TLX. Its 3 HP motor, 12 mph top speed, 12% incline, 20 × 60-inch deck and larger 7-inch display make…
See the winner →
ProForm Carbon TL vs NordicTrack T Series 5
Overall winner for budget buyers: ProForm Carbon TL, by a small margin. It matches the T Series 5 on motor, speed, incline, deck and display, and…
See the winner →
Horizon T101 vs ProForm Carbon TL
Overall winner for small spaces: Horizon T101. It pairs a folding frame with a 20 × 55-inch deck, quick dial controls, six built-in programs,…
See the winner →Brand vs Brand
How the big treadmill brands differ in lineup, motors, decks, apps and warranty.
NordicTrack vs ProForm
Choose NordicTrack if you want the deeper running lineup: 22-inch-wide Commercial decks, motors up to 4.25 HP, 3% decline and touchscreens up to 24…
Compare the brands →
Sole vs NordicTrack
Choose Sole if you want a running treadmill with lifetime frame and motor coverage, up to 15% incline and no required membership; the TT8 and F89 add…
Compare the brands →
Horizon vs NordicTrack
Choose Horizon Fitness if you want a straightforward treadmill with QuickDial controls, up to 15% incline, lifetime frame and motor coverage and no…
Compare the brands →
Sole vs Horizon Treadmill
Choose Sole if you want the strongest running decks, 4 HP flagships, decline on the F89 and TT8 and a free brand app. Choose Horizon if you want fast…
Compare the brands →
Bowflex vs NordicTrack Treadmill
Choose NordicTrack if you want trainer-led iFIT classes, large touchscreens, decline on the Commercial models and the widest range, from walking to…
Compare the brands →
Sole vs Bowflex Treadmill
Choose Sole if you run, want stronger motors, 22 × 60-inch decks, decline on the F89 and TT8 and a free app with no membership. Choose Bowflex if you…
Compare the brands →
ProForm vs Horizon Treadmill
Choose ProForm if you want trainer-led iFIT classes that change speed and incline for you, led by the Pro 9000 and its 16-inch touchscreen. Choose…
Compare the brands →Treadmill vs Other Options
Treadmills against walking pads, ellipticals, bikes, stair climbers and running outside.
Treadmill vs Walking Pad
Choose a full treadmill if you want to run, jog fast, train on steep incline or share the machine with tall or heavy users. Choose a walking pad if…
Compare →
Curved vs Flat Treadmill
Choose a curved treadmill if you want self-paced sprints and intervals with no motor and no top speed, and you accept a harder effort at any pace.…
Compare →
Manual vs Electric Treadmill
Choose an electric treadmill if you want set speeds, adjustable incline, a full-size deck for walking or running and the widest choice of models.…
Compare →
Treadmill vs Exercise Bike
Choose a treadmill if you want weight-bearing exercise, walking or running that carries over to daily life and races, and incline for harder…
Compare →
Treadmill vs Elliptical
Choose a treadmill if you want to walk, run or train for races, since it builds weight-bearing fitness and lets you use incline. Choose an elliptical…
Compare →
Treadmill vs StairMaster
Choose a StairMaster-style stair climber if you want the most work per minute and a hard glute and quad burn. Choose a treadmill if you want one…
Compare →
Treadmill vs Running Outside
Run outside when you are training for a road race, want varied terrain or enjoy the scenery. Use a treadmill for controlled pace, softer landings,…
Compare →Still deciding?
Our ranked buying guides list the five best treadmills for each need, scored with FitScore.
See the best treadmills