FitScore for Wooden Plyo Boxes · product photos from Amazon
Yes4All vs Amazon Basics Plyo Box: Yes4All vs Amazon Basics: two 12/14/16 in wooden boxes from our best wooden plyo boxes guide. Both are wooden boxes with built-in handles and a 450 lb stated capacity; the Yes4All adds puzzle joints and the Amazon Basics adds height indicators. New to heights: read the plyo box size guide.
Quick Verdict
Overall winner for a wooden plyo box: Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in, by 5.5 points (70.4 against 64.9) with the weights of our best wooden plyo boxes guide. It leads on durability. The Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in leads on features.
- Yes4All vs Amazon Basics Plyo Box: Jump Heights: tie
- Capacity and Build: Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in
- Landing and Grip: tie
- Setup and Handling: tie
- Sizes and Marks: Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in
Head-to-Head Specs
Here are the two side by side. A check mark shows the stronger spec on each line. Check both warranties before you order: the FTC explains how to read a product warranty. The CDC recommends at least 150 minutes of moderate or 75 minutes of vigorous aerobic activity a week for adults.
| Comparehead to head | WinnerBest overall wooden box![]() | Best low-cost box with height marks![]() |
|---|---|---|
| Heights | 12 to 16 in | 12 to 16 in |
| Capacity | 450 lb | 450 lb |
| Landing surface | Hard | Hard |
| Non-slip top | Yes | Yes |
| Specs won (✓) Lines where the model has the stronger spec; ties count for neither | 0 of 4 | 0 of 4 |
| Check Price | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
Check Amazon for current pricing and availability.
FitScore Duel
Both scores use the weights of our best wooden plyo boxes guide (how we score). Durability (30%) counts most, then performance (25%), affordability (20%), comfort and practicality (10% each) and features (5%). The Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in ranks #1 in that guide. The Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in ranks #2 in that guide.
Key Differences

Yes4All vs Amazon Basics Plyo Box: Jump Heights
The tallest height decides how far the box can progress, and the lowest one how gentle the first step is.
Top height: both list 16 in.
Lowest height: both list 12 in.
Performance score in this comparison: Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 70, Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 70.
Winner: Tie
Capacity and Build
Capacity: both list 450 lb.
Solid core: Yes on the Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in; not stated on the Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in.
Finish: both list smooth.
Durability score in this comparison: Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 85.04, Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 60.16.
Winner: Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in
Landing and Grip
A soft landing surface and a non-slip top decide how safe each landing feels.
Landing surface: both list hard.
Non-slip top: both list yes.
Comfort score in this comparison: Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 60, Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 60.
Winner: Tie
Setup and Handling
Arriving assembled, built-in handles and a wipe-clean cover decide how fast you start and how easy it is to move and clean.
Assembly: both list assembly needed.
Handles: both list built in.
Practicality score in this comparison: Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 30, Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 30.
Winner: Tie
Sizes and Marks
Several box sizes and height markings round out the box.
Height marks: Yes on the Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in; not stated on the Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in.
Features score in this comparison: Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 0, Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in 40.
Winner: Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in
Who Should Buy Each
A firmer build: Pick the Yes4All for puzzle joints and wide built-in handles at a low cost.
Easy-to-read heights: Pick the Amazon Basics for height indicators that make each setting easy to read.
Consider Instead
If neither fits, look at the Fitvids Wooden Plyo Box 16/20/24 in: it offers a higher performance and features score than the Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in. It ranks #3 in our best wooden plyo boxes guide.
Final Verdict
Overall winner for a wooden plyo box: Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in. Pick the Yes4All for the joined plywood build; pick the Amazon Basics for the height indicators.
Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in vs Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in FAQ
With the weights of our best wooden plyo boxes guide, the Yes4All Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in scores higher: 70.4 against 64.9. It leads on durability, while the Amazon Basics Wooden Plyo Box 12/14/16 in leads on features.
Both are 12/14/16 in wooden boxes with built-in handles, sanded edges and a 450 lb stated capacity; the Yes4All has puzzle joints and the Amazon Basics has height indicators.
Either: both start at 12 in, which suits step-ups and low jumps; see our plyo box size guide.
Yes, both wooden boxes need assembly with the included hardware and pre-drilled holes.
This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We do not show prices because they change constantly: product details and availability can change at any time, so please check the current price and details directly on Amazon. Learn more. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.






