Yes4All vs RDX Sandbag (2026): Which Workout Sandbag Should You Buy?

Our recommendations are based on product specs and use-case fit. Affiliate links included. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our disclosure

Winner
Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb

More load

Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb

FitScore for Sandbag

  • WarrantyNot stated

Choose it if you want one bag that grows to 200 lb.

RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb

More handles

RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb

FitScore for Sandbag

  • WarrantyNot stated

Choose it for circuits with many grips and a heavier shell.

Overall winner for sandbag training at home: Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb, by 8 points (66.9 against 58.9) with the weights of our best sandbag guide. It leads on performance, practicality and affordability. The RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb leads on features.

  • Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb wins 2 rounds
  • RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb wins 1 round
  • =2 ties

Product photos from Amazon. FitScore weights are explained below.

Yes4All vs RDX sandbag: two handle bags from the top 5 of our best sandbag for working out. The Yes4All XL takes 125 to 200 lb with seven handles; the RDX medium takes 25 to 75 lb with eight handles and two inner bags in a 1200D shell. For the shapes, read Bulgarian bag vs sandbag.

Head-to-Head Specs

Here are the two side by side. A check mark shows the stronger spec on each line. Check both warranties before you order: the FTC explains how to read a product warranty. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans advise adults to do muscle-strengthening activity, like lifting weights or push-ups, at least 2 days each week.

Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb vs RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb head-to-head specifications
SpecificationYes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lbFitScore 66.9RDX Sandbag 25-75 lbFitScore 58.9
TypeWorkout sandbagWorkout sandbag
Max load200 lb✓75 lb
Shell1000D Cordura or nylon1000D Cordura or nylon
Handles78✓
ClosureDouble or sealedDouble or sealed
Adjustable loadYesYes
WarrantyNot statedNot stated
Specs won1 of 71 of 7

Check Amazon for current pricing and availability.

FitScore Duel

Both scores use the weights of our best sandbag guide (how we score). Durability (30%) counts most, then performance (25%), comfort and practicality (15% each), affordability (10%) and features (5%). The Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb ranks #1 in that guide. The RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb ranks #4 in that guide.

Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb66.9
FitScore for Sandbag
RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb58.9
100
Performanceweight 25%
80
56.24
Durabilityweight 30%
56.24
0
Comfortweight 15%
0
100
Practicalityweight 15%
80
0
Featuresweight 5%
25
100
Affordabilityweight 10%
88

Key Differences

  1. Max load: 200 lb on the Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb; 75 lb on the RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb.
  2. Handles: 7 on the Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb; 8 on the RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb.
Yes4All vs RDX sandbag: woman lifting a black workout sandbag with handles in a garage gym
Pick the bag for the load you need in a year. (Illustration, not an actual product photo.)

Round 1 of 5

Yes4All vs RDX Sandbag: Load and Handles

Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb wins this round

Max load: 200 lb on the Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb, 75 lb on the RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb.

Adjustable load: both list yes.

Handles: 7 on the Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb, 8 on the RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb.

Performance score in this comparison: Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb 100, RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb 80.

Round 2 of 5

Shell and Seams

Tie. Neither model has a clear edge here.

Shell: both list 1000D Cordura or nylon.

Seams: both list reinforced.

The RDX shell is 1200D Cordura; the Yes4All shell is 1000D nylon.

Durability score in this comparison: Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb 56.24, RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb 56.24.

Round 3 of 5

Grips and Shape

Tie. Neither model has a clear edge here.

Padded handles and a shape that sits on the shoulder make heavy sets easier to hold.

Padded handles: both list no.

Shoulder shape: both list no.

Comfort score in this comparison: Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb 0, RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb 0.

Round 4 of 5

Filling and Closure

Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb wins this round

Filler bags in the box and a double closure keep the sand in and the setup quick.

Closure: both list double or sealed.

Practicality score in this comparison: Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb 100, RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb 80.

Round 5 of 5

Filler Bags and Extras

RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb wins this round

More filler bags, a carry bag and an exercise guide add range.

Filler bags: 2 on the RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb; not stated on the Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb.

Exercise guide: both list no.

Features score in this comparison: Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb 0, RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb 25.

Who Should Buy Each

Room to grow

Pick Yes4All for 125 to 200 lb in one bag.

Circuit grips

Pick RDX for eight handles and two inner bags.

Consider Instead

Titan Fitness PRO Strongman Sandbag 50-125 lb

Titan Fitness PRO Strongman Sandbag 50-125 lb

If neither fits, look at the Titan Fitness PRO Strongman Sandbag 50-125 lb: it offers a higher durability and comfort score than the Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb. It ranks #2 in our best sandbag guide.

Read the Titan Fitness PRO Strongman Sandbag 50-125 lb review

Final Verdict

Overall winner for sandbag training at home: Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb. Pick Yes4All for heavy loads and progression; pick RDX for lighter circuits with eight grips.

Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lbCheck price
RDX Sandbag 25-75 lbCheck price

Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb vs RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb FAQ

With the weights of our best sandbag guide, the Yes4All Sandbag XL 125-200 lb scores higher: 66.9 against 58.9. It leads on performance, practicality and affordability, while the RDX Sandbag 25-75 lb leads on features.

The Yes4All XL holds far more sand; the RDX medium has more handles, two inner bags and a 1200D shell.

No: both ship empty with inner bags for the sand.

Neither is sold as a slam bag; Yes4All says its bag is made for lifting only.

This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We do not show prices because they change constantly: product details and availability can change at any time, so please check the current price and details directly on Amazon. Learn more. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.