VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P)
Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042)
FitScore for Ab Roller · product photos from Amazon
VINSGUIR vs Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro: the top two of our best ab rollers. The VINSGUIR has dual 3.2-inch wheels and a 500 lb rating at 1.41 lb; the Ab Carver Pro adds a spring and a 1-year warranty, rated for 220 lb. For the types, read ab roller vs ab machine.
Quick Verdict
Overall winner for ab roller workouts: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P), by 4 points (63.2 against 59.2) with the weights of our best ab roller guide. It leads on comfort, affordability and practicality. The Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042) leads on durability.
Best value
VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P)
FitScore 63.2/100
Choose it if you want a stable, light roller with a high rating.
Best spring assist
Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042)
FitScore 59.2/100
Choose it if you want help on the roll-back.
- VINSGUIR vs Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro: Workout Range: tie
- Warranty: Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042)
- Knee Pad and Capacity: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P)
- Weight and Storage: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P)
- Guide and Extras: tie
Head-to-Head Specs
Here are the two side by side. A check mark shows the stronger spec on each line. Check both warranties before you order: the FTC explains how to read a product warranty. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans advise adults to do muscle-strengthening activity, like lifting weights or push-ups, at least 2 days each week.
| Comparehead to head | WinnerBest value | Best spring assist |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Ab roller wheel | Ab roller wheel |
| Wheels | 2 | 1 |
| Spring | No | Yes |
| Knee pad | Included | Included |
| Max user weight | 500 lb ✓ | 220 lb |
| Weight | 1.41 lb ✓ | 4.63 lb |
| Warranty | Not stated | 1 year ✓ |
| Specs won (✓) Lines where the model has the stronger spec; ties count for neither | 2 of 7 | 1 of 7 |
| Check Price | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
Check Amazon for current pricing and availability.
FitScore Duel
Both scores use the weights of our best ab roller guide (how we score). Performance (30%) counts most, then comfort (20%), durability and affordability (15% each) and practicality and features (10% each). The VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P) ranks #1 in that guide. The Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042) ranks #2 in that guide.
Key Differences
- Wheels: 2 on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P); 1 on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042).
- Spring: No on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P); Yes on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042).
- Max user weight: 500 lb on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P); 220 lb on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042).
- Weight: 1.41 lb on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P); 4.63 lb on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042).
- Warranty: not stated on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P); 1 year on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042).
VINSGUIR vs Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro: Workout Range
Spring: No on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P), Yes on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042).
Wheels: 2 on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P), 1 on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042).
Display: both list no.
Performance score in this comparison: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P) 60, Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042) 60.
Winner: Tie
Warranty
The warranty is the stated measure of how long ab equipment lasts.
Warranty: 1 year on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042); not stated on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P).
Durability score in this comparison: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P) 8.24, Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042) 59.64.
Winner: Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042)
Knee Pad and Capacity
Knee pad: both list included.
Max user weight: 500 lb on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P), 220 lb on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042).
The VINSGUIR is rated for 500 lb; the Ab Carver Pro for 220 lb.
Comfort score in this comparison: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P) 100, Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042) 72.
Winner: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P)
Weight and Storage
Weight and folding decide where it lives.
Weight: 1.41 lb on the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P), 4.63 lb on the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042).
Practicality score in this comparison: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P) 60, Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042) 50.
Winner: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P)
Guide and Extras
An exercise guide and extras in the box differ in what they offer.
Guide: both list included.
Features score in this comparison: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P) 30, Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042) 30.
Winner: Tie
Who Should Buy Each
A stable first roller: Pick the VINSGUIR for dual wheels, a knee pad and a 500 lb rating.
Guided rollouts: Pick the Ab Carver Pro for a spring, knee pads and a workout guide.
Consider Instead
If neither fits, look at the GoFit Super Ab Wheel (GF-DDW): it offers another ranked pick of our best ab roller guide. It ranks #3 in our best ab roller guide.
Final Verdict
Overall winner for ab roller workouts: VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P). Pick the VINSGUIR for stability and a high weight rating; pick the Ab Carver Pro for spring-assisted rollouts and a 1-year warranty.
VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P) vs Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042) FAQ
With the weights of our best ab roller guide, the VINSGUIR Ab Roller (VG-220TPRABR1P) scores higher: 63.2 against 59.2. It leads on comfort, affordability and practicality, while the Perfect Fitness Ab Carver Pro (31042) leads on durability.
The VINSGUIR has two plain wheels and a 500 lb rating; the Ab Carver Pro has a spring-assisted wide wheel and a 220 lb rating.
The Ab Carver Pro.
The VINSGUIR, at 1.41 lb against 4.63 lb.
This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We do not show prices because they change constantly: product details and availability can change at any time, so please check the current price and details directly on Amazon. Learn more. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.
