FitScore for Budget Ski Erg · product photos from Amazon
Marcy vs GMWD Ski Trainer: Marcy vs GMWD: the two lower-priced ski ergs at the top of our best budget ski erg guide. The GMWD adds a floor stand and a lifetime frame warranty on eligible frames; the Marcy adds an air flywheel and ergonomic handles on a wall mount. New to ski ergs: read wall mount vs floor stand.
Quick Verdict
Overall winner for a budget ski erg: GMWD Air Ski Machine, by 2.4 points (76 against 73.6) with the weights of our best budget ski erg guide. It leads on practicality and durability. The Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357 leads on affordability, performance and comfort.
- Marcy vs GMWD Ski Trainer: Resistance and Power: Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357
- Build and Warranty: GMWD Air Ski Machine
- Handles and Stroke: Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357
- Mounting and Storage: GMWD Air Ski Machine
- Monitor and Extras: tie
Head-to-Head Specs
Here are the two side by side. A check mark shows the stronger spec on each line. Check both warranties before you order: the FTC explains how to read a product warranty. The CDC recommends at least 150 minutes of moderate or 75 minutes of vigorous aerobic activity a week for adults.
| Comparehead to head | WinnerBest with a stand included![]() | Best air flywheel on a wall![]() |
|---|---|---|
| Resistance | Fan and magnet | Air flywheel ✓ |
| Levels | 10 levels | 10 levels |
| Mounting | Wall or floor stand | Wall mount |
| Monitor power | Watts or pace | Watts or pace |
| App | Not stated | Not stated |
| Heart rate | Not stated | Not stated |
| Warranty | Lifetime ✓ | 2 years |
| Specs won (✓) Lines where the model has the stronger spec; ties count for neither | 1 of 7 | 1 of 7 |
| Check Price | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
Check Amazon for current pricing and availability.
FitScore Duel
Both scores use the weights of our best budget ski erg guide (how we score). Affordability (25%) counts most, then performance and practicality (20% each), durability (15%) and comfort and features (10% each). The GMWD Air Ski Machine ranks #1 in that guide. The Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357 ranks #2 in that guide.
Key Differences
- Resistance: Fan and magnet on the GMWD Air Ski Machine; Air flywheel on the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357.
- Mounting: Wall or floor stand on the GMWD Air Ski Machine; Wall mount on the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357.
- Warranty: Lifetime on the GMWD Air Ski Machine; 2 years on the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357.

Marcy vs GMWD Ski Trainer: Resistance and Power
Resistance: Fan and magnet on the GMWD Air Ski Machine, Air flywheel on the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357.
Levels: both list 10 levels.
Monitor power: both list watts or pace.
Performance score in this comparison: GMWD Air Ski Machine 92, Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357 100.
Winner: Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357
Build and Warranty
Commercial use and the frame warranty are the stated measures of build.
Commercial use: Yes on the GMWD Air Ski Machine, No on the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357.
Warranty: Lifetime on the GMWD Air Ski Machine, 2 years on the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357.
Durability score in this comparison: GMWD Air Ski Machine 90.68, Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357 57.2.
Winner: GMWD Air Ski Machine
Handles and Stroke
Ergonomic handles and double-pull or alternating strokes shape how each pull feels.
Ergonomic handles: both list yes.
Double pull: Yes on the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357; not stated on the GMWD Air Ski Machine.
Comfort score in this comparison: GMWD Air Ski Machine 50, Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357 100.
Winner: Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357
Mounting and Storage
Wall mount: both list yes.
Floor stand: Included on the GMWD Air Ski Machine, Not included on the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357.
Wheels: No on the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357; not stated on the GMWD Air Ski Machine.
Practicality score in this comparison: GMWD Air Ski Machine 70, Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357 40.
Winner: GMWD Air Ski Machine
Monitor and Extras
A monitor, an app and a heart rate connection round out the machine.
Monitor: both list yes.
Features score in this comparison: GMWD Air Ski Machine 40, Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357 40.
Winner: Tie
Who Should Buy Each
A flexible setup: Pick the GMWD if you may move the machine or cannot drill into a wall: it mounts either way.
A garage with a stud wall: Pick the Marcy for an air flywheel bolted into a stud, with ergonomic handles and a wattage display.
Consider Instead
If neither fits, look at the Sunny Magnetic Ski Trainer: it offers a higher features score than the GMWD Air Ski Machine. It ranks #3 in our best budget ski erg guide.
Final Verdict
Overall winner for a budget ski erg: GMWD Air Ski Machine. Pick the GMWD for the stand and the stronger warranty; pick the Marcy for air resistance on a stud wall.
GMWD Air Ski Machine vs Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357 FAQ
With the weights of our best budget ski erg guide, the GMWD Air Ski Machine scores higher: 76 against 73.6. It leads on practicality and durability, while the Marcy Ski Trainer NS-0357 leads on affordability, performance and comfort.
Both have 10 levels and a monitor with watts; the GMWD includes a floor stand and a lifetime frame warranty on eligible frames, the Marcy is wall-mounted air resistance with ergonomic handles and a 2-year warranty.
The Marcy version we compared bolts to a wall stud; the GMWD works on a wall or on its floor stand.
Both suit a garage: the GMWD if you want the choice of wall or floor, the Marcy if you have a stud wall.
This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We do not show prices because they change constantly: product details and availability can change at any time, so please check the current price and details directly on Amazon. Learn more. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.





