FitScore for Cold Plunge Tub With Chiller · product photos from Amazon
1stplunge vs As Coldplunge: 1stplunge 216 vs AS ColdPlunge 148: two tub-and-chiller kits, both with a 1/3 HP chiller, both in our best cold plunge tub with chiller guide. The 1stplunge adds 68 gallons and app control; the AS ColdPlunge is smaller. See inflatable vs chiller kit.
Quick Verdict
Overall winner for a cold plunge tub with a chiller: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit, by 7.2 points (70 against 62.8) with the weights of our best cold plunge tub with chiller guide. It leads on performance and features. The AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit leads on affordability.
- 1stplunge vs As Coldplunge: Cooling and Capacity: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit
- Build and Warranty: tie
- Room and Depth: tie
- Lid and Setup: tie
- Controls and Extras: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit
Head-to-Head Specs
Here are the two side by side. A check mark shows the stronger spec on each line. Check both warranties before you order: the FTC explains how to read a product warranty. A chiller needs a power outlet near the tub, so plan the outlet first: the CPSC explains how to limit extension cord use to reduce the risk of fire.
| Comparehead to head | WinnerBest overall kit![]() | Best mid-size kit![]() |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Tub and chiller kit | Tub and chiller kit |
| Capacity | 216 gallons ✓ | 148 gallons |
| Chiller | In the box | In the box |
| Lid | Not stated | Not stated |
| Filter | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 1 year | 1 year |
| Specs won (✓) Lines where the model has the stronger spec; ties count for neither | 1 of 6 | 0 of 6 |
| Check Price | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
Check Amazon for current pricing and availability.
FitScore Duel
Both scores use the weights of our best cold plunge tub with chiller guide (how we score). Performance (35%) counts most, then durability and features (20% each), comfort and practicality (10% each) and affordability (5%). The 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit ranks #1 in that guide. The AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit ranks #2 in that guide. The order flips with other weights: in our best portable cold plunge tub guide the AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit scores 48.5 against 47.6 for the 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit.
Key Differences
- Capacity: 216 gallons on the 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit; 148 gallons on the AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit.

1stplunge vs As Coldplunge: Cooling and Capacity
Capacity: 216 gallons on the 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit, 148 gallons on the AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit.
Lowest temperature: both list 42 F.
Chiller: both list in the box.
Performance score in this comparison: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit 95, AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit 89.
Winner: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit
Build and Warranty
The insulated wall and the warranty are the stated measures of build.
Insulated wall: both list multi-layer.
Warranty: both list 1 year.
Durability score in this comparison: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit 72.24, AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit 72.24.
Winner: Tie
Room and Depth
Room for tall users and the depth of the tub shape how you sit in it.
Comfort score in this comparison: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit 0, AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit 0.
Winner: Tie
Lid and Setup
A lid, a drain and a carry bag decide how easily the tub lives in your home.
Practicality score in this comparison: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit 0, AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit 0.
Winner: Tie
Controls and Extras
Filter: both list yes.
Display: both list yes.
App: Yes on the 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit; not stated on the AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit.
Features score in this comparison: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit 100, AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit 70.
Winner: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit
Who Should Buy Each
A buyer who wants the most controls: Pick the 1stplunge for 216 gallons, a built-in pump with a washable mesh filter and WiFi app control.
A buyer with a tighter space: Pick the AS ColdPlunge for a 148-gallon oval tub with an external pump, a 20-micron filter and an LED touchscreen.
Consider Instead
If neither fits, look at the 1stplunge 148 Gal WiFi Kit: it offers a higher affordability score than the 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit. It ranks #3 in our best cold plunge tub with chiller guide.
Final Verdict
Overall winner for a cold plunge tub with a chiller: 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit. Pick the 1stplunge for capacity and app control; pick the AS ColdPlunge for a smaller footprint with a touchscreen and a filter.
1stplunge 216 Gal Kit vs AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit FAQ
With the weights of our best cold plunge tub with chiller guide, the 1stplunge 216 Gal Kit scores higher: 70 against 62.8. It leads on performance and features, while the AS ColdPlunge 148 Gal Kit leads on affordability.
Both are tub-and-chiller kits with a 1/3 HP chiller; the 1stplunge holds 216 gallons and adds WiFi app control, the AS ColdPlunge holds 148 gallons and has an LED touchscreen.
The 1stplunge, at 216 gallons against 148.
Yes, both kits include a 1/3 HP chiller; the makers ship the tub and the chiller in separate boxes.
This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We do not show prices because they change constantly: product details and availability can change at any time, so please check the current price and details directly on Amazon. Learn more. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.





